I want to be clear. The rating is that of “not my cup,” meaning that this book isn’t bad, but it wasn’t for me. So please don’t hate me for that.
The thing is, I couldn’t for the life of me figure out this book. Storywise it was a complete mess for me
I want to be clear. The rating is that of “not my cup,” meaning that this book isn’t bad, but it wasn’t for me. So please don’t hate me for that.
The thing is, I couldn’t for the life of me figure out this book. Storywise it was a complete mess for me (probably because it’s the final book of a series and we are thrown into it with reckless abandon). That, and it was like Contemporary and Fantasy tried to both squeeze themselves through one very narrow door. In result, they both end up exhausted and on the floor. There were no real descriptions or relatively any means of building a world, because it was piggybacking on all these fandoms that we know and love.
Which in a way makes this the best fanfiction ever. It’s true! This is a great ode to the many ideas we see in books, films, and music. The problem is there is nothing interesting to me because of this. Rowell focuses so much on the references (which she does an amazing job at) that it takes away from the actual plot. Other than the references, the charming dialogue, and maybe the last 100 pages...I wasn’t impressed.
But I’m also very particular about fanfiction in general. I don’t like people twisting the characters I’ve grown to love. Changing their personality. Making them do things they wouldn’t normally do. Making them gay just for the means of satisfaction. However, there are some writers that do wonderful things with these characters and make them true to who they are. Those are the ones I find worth reading because it’s like another adventure with your favorite people.
Either way, reading this book was like watching a group of my friends having an inside joke that’s so memorable and funny that tears are streaming down their eyes from the laughter and familiarity...while I’m just stuck standing there thinking, “I don’t get it.” And let me tell you guys, that’s not really a good feeling.
The only thing I really enjoyed was Simon and Baz's relationship and that's mainly because I'm a sucker for the enemies-to-lovers trope. Plus, Rowell knows how to write the perfect kiss scenes. People do love and connect with it so I say give it a chance, but expect to be clueless for a while, because it takes a long time for the ball to get rolling with this read....more
"
133 votes
Yes! The popular author of the Throne of Glass series is back with book four, Queen of Shadows, and she has answers to your questions! Read on for her characters' fave books and her best advice to new authors!