
Fables #1
Fables, Vol. 1: Legends in Exile
When a savage creature known only as the Adversary conquered the fabled lands of legends and fairy tales, all of the infamous inhabitants of folklore were forced into exile. Disguised among the normal citizens of modern-day New York, these magical characters have created their own peaceful and secret society within an exclusive luxury apartment building called Fabletown. But when Snow White's party-girl sister, Rose Red, is apparently murdered, it is up to Fabletown's sheriff, a reformed and pardoned Big Bad Wolf (Bigby Wolf), to determine if the killer is Bluebeard, Rose's ex-lover and notorious wife killer, or Jack, her current live-in boyfriend and former beanstalk-climber.
Collecting: Fables 1-5
Collecting: Fables 1-5
128 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2002
Will Eisner Comic Industry Awards, Best Serialized Story, Best New Series (2003)
In the late 1970s to early 1980s he drew fantasy ink pictures for the Dungeons & Dragons Basic and Expert game rulebooks. He first gained attention for his 1980s comic book series Elementals published by Comico, which he both wrote and drew. However, for reasons unknown, the series had trouble maintaining an original schedule, and Willingham's position in the industry remained spotty for many years. He contributed stories to Green Lantern and started his own independent, black-and-white comics series Coventry which lasted only 3 issues. He also produced the pornographic series Ironwood for Eros Comix.
In the late 1990s Willingham reestablished himself as a prolific writer. He produced the 13-issue Pantheon for Lone Star Press and wrote a pair of short novels about the modern adventures of the hero Beowulf, published by the writer's collective, Clockwork Storybook, of which Willingham was a founding member. In the early 2000s he began writing extensively for DC Comics, including the limited series Proposition Player, a pair of limited series about the Greek witch Thessaly from The Sandman, and most notably the popular series Fables
In the late 1990s Willingham reestablished himself as a prolific writer. He produced the 13-issue Pantheon for Lone Star Press and wrote a pair of short novels about the modern adventures of the hero Beowulf, published by the writer's collective, Clockwork Storybook, of which Willingham was a founding member. In the early 2000s he began writing extensively for DC Comics, including the limited series Proposition Player, a pair of limited series about the Greek witch Thessaly from The Sandman, and most notably the popular series Fables
Ratings & Reviews
Community Reviews
Edited May 17, 2021
Legends in Exile is a fun (possible) murder-mystery with a fairytale twist.
As in, everyone in the story is a part of a fairytale. Their lands have been taken over by someone known only as The Adversary, and they've banded together here in our world as a tight community who are determined to keep their true nature a secret from outsiders.

Alright, so I read this about 12 years ago the first time around, and unsurprisingly, I remembered very little about the plot.
The actual mystery is good but is made so much better because it involves all of these different characters that you read about as a child. Beauty and the Beast, Snow White, The Big Bad Wolf, Jack (of and the Beanstalk fame), Rose Red, Bluebeard, King Cole, and quite a few more make appearances as part of the cast.

Rose Red is DEAD! <--or is she?
She's gone missing and her apartment is covered in blood. So while there's no body, things aren't looking good for Snow White's sister.

Bigby Wolf (<--get it?) is investigating her disappearance, collecting clues, and interrogating the suspects. Snow White, who is the mayor's right hand, has inserted herself into the investigation and is intent on helping find out what happened to her sister.
However, it was the reappearance of Snow White's ex, the smarmy Prince Charming, that really stole the show for me.
I've heard less than favorable things about the series in later years, but I think I'm still going to continue with it for now.
As in, everyone in the story is a part of a fairytale. Their lands have been taken over by someone known only as The Adversary, and they've banded together here in our world as a tight community who are determined to keep their true nature a secret from outsiders.

Alright, so I read this about 12 years ago the first time around, and unsurprisingly, I remembered very little about the plot.
The actual mystery is good but is made so much better because it involves all of these different characters that you read about as a child. Beauty and the Beast, Snow White, The Big Bad Wolf, Jack (of and the Beanstalk fame), Rose Red, Bluebeard, King Cole, and quite a few more make appearances as part of the cast.

Rose Red is DEAD! <--or is she?
She's gone missing and her apartment is covered in blood. So while there's no body, things aren't looking good for Snow White's sister.

Bigby Wolf (<--get it?) is investigating her disappearance, collecting clues, and interrogating the suspects. Snow White, who is the mayor's right hand, has inserted herself into the investigation and is intent on helping find out what happened to her sister.
However, it was the reappearance of Snow White's ex, the smarmy Prince Charming, that really stole the show for me.
I've heard less than favorable things about the series in later years, but I think I'm still going to continue with it for now.
November 11, 2010
I remember being somewhat taken aback the first time I read an original Fairy Tale. They aren't child-friendly, in fact many of them were written to unnerve and frighten children. The characters in fairytales are usually half-mad, murderous, sexually-charged, and grotesque.
Authors have returned to them again and again for inspiration, exploring the history of storytelling, moralizing tales, propaganda, and archetypes. Gaiman's 'Sandman' is notable for some remarkable insights into the nature of fairy tales and how they comment on what has changed in our modern storytelling tradition--and what hasn't. Likewise Mignola has recalled to us some of the less pleasant aspects of fairy stories in 'Hellboy', where the madness of these myths is hardly forgotten.
Hellboy was a decade before Fables, and Sandman twenty years before, but Fables is, if anything, a regression, doing less with myth than earlier comics. Names are dropped, but the characters attached neither typify nor subvert the characters they are aping. In the end, Willingham portrays a less nuanced take on the original myth than the average Disney movie.
His dialogue is wooden, lacking in subtlety or thrust. The characters say what you would expect them to, with plenty of awkward exposition:
"Todd, my brother, what are you doing here at the government headquarters when you should be searching for your lost wife?"
There's no style or charm to be found in the writing and the characters show none of the grotesque vividness of their sources.
Willingham seems unable to imagine a larger world than the one directly implied by his plot, which is a straightforward murder-mystery. His setting has all the depth of a painted backdrop. If he had hoped to achieve a sliver of what Gaiman did with old myths, he should have delved deeper into his source materials.
His interweaving is clumsy, with the suggestion that Oz and 'The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe' are part of his fairytale tradition. This inclusion conflicts with the backstory, since both were written after the fables were ousted from fairy land and relocated to America (the result of a war with Satan in a flashback swiped from 'The Lord of The Rings' Films).
The art is workmanlike, often as wooden and simplified as the dialogue. It tells the story with little flair or movement. Characters are successfully reproduced, but not explored or played with. Most of the frames are closeups of people talking, and the rest are mid-range bird's eye group shots. It's all yawningly safe. The color palate shows little variance or mood, more 'Jughead Digest' than Vertigo, and lacking even the lurid appeal of a 4-color.
Once again I'm haunted by the phrase "it gets better!", which is all the more maddening because in a tiny fraction of cases, it proves to be true. Unfortunately, the next two volumes don't get much better, though with practice, the dull, awkward storytelling does get more streamlined, which is kind of like a bad restaurant which puts out fliers to announce that it now has delivery service.
Mediocrity is one of the few things made worse by improving its convenience.
I usually save one-star reviews for books that were overtly insulting or stupid, but this one gets it purely on uninspired dullness. I tried reading it when it first came out, and couldn't get through it. After hearing all the praise more recently, I tried again. I'm not going to be one of those who says that comics used to be better and suck now, I know there must be good comics out right now, but they can be hard to find. I'm back to looking, it seems.
My Suggested Readings in Comics
Authors have returned to them again and again for inspiration, exploring the history of storytelling, moralizing tales, propaganda, and archetypes. Gaiman's 'Sandman' is notable for some remarkable insights into the nature of fairy tales and how they comment on what has changed in our modern storytelling tradition--and what hasn't. Likewise Mignola has recalled to us some of the less pleasant aspects of fairy stories in 'Hellboy', where the madness of these myths is hardly forgotten.
Hellboy was a decade before Fables, and Sandman twenty years before, but Fables is, if anything, a regression, doing less with myth than earlier comics. Names are dropped, but the characters attached neither typify nor subvert the characters they are aping. In the end, Willingham portrays a less nuanced take on the original myth than the average Disney movie.
His dialogue is wooden, lacking in subtlety or thrust. The characters say what you would expect them to, with plenty of awkward exposition:
"Todd, my brother, what are you doing here at the government headquarters when you should be searching for your lost wife?"
There's no style or charm to be found in the writing and the characters show none of the grotesque vividness of their sources.
Willingham seems unable to imagine a larger world than the one directly implied by his plot, which is a straightforward murder-mystery. His setting has all the depth of a painted backdrop. If he had hoped to achieve a sliver of what Gaiman did with old myths, he should have delved deeper into his source materials.
His interweaving is clumsy, with the suggestion that Oz and 'The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe' are part of his fairytale tradition. This inclusion conflicts with the backstory, since both were written after the fables were ousted from fairy land and relocated to America (the result of a war with Satan in a flashback swiped from 'The Lord of The Rings' Films).
The art is workmanlike, often as wooden and simplified as the dialogue. It tells the story with little flair or movement. Characters are successfully reproduced, but not explored or played with. Most of the frames are closeups of people talking, and the rest are mid-range bird's eye group shots. It's all yawningly safe. The color palate shows little variance or mood, more 'Jughead Digest' than Vertigo, and lacking even the lurid appeal of a 4-color.
Once again I'm haunted by the phrase "it gets better!", which is all the more maddening because in a tiny fraction of cases, it proves to be true. Unfortunately, the next two volumes don't get much better, though with practice, the dull, awkward storytelling does get more streamlined, which is kind of like a bad restaurant which puts out fliers to announce that it now has delivery service.
Mediocrity is one of the few things made worse by improving its convenience.
I usually save one-star reviews for books that were overtly insulting or stupid, but this one gets it purely on uninspired dullness. I tried reading it when it first came out, and couldn't get through it. After hearing all the praise more recently, I tried again. I'm not going to be one of those who says that comics used to be better and suck now, I know there must be good comics out right now, but they can be hard to find. I'm back to looking, it seems.
My Suggested Readings in Comics
Edited April 30, 2013
I'd been wondering why lately I've had such bad luck with books. Almost everything I picked up went back down again and more than half of what I read through and reviewed was a disappointment. After reading this first volume of the Fables series, it hit me all of a sudden - Tatiana. Or lack of Tatiana and her excellent book-recommending skills. Thanks for the rec, T, I knew you'd get it right ^_^
The Fables series has been one I've wanted to start since I first heard of it. Adult retellings of classic fairytales with a few touches of sex, violence and humour? SOLD! However, I talked myself out of it about a year ago when I foolishly picked up a random volume - nine, I believe - and didn't get it at all. Perhaps volume nine happens to be a bad apple in an otherwise excellent bunch, or perhaps that particular volume wasn't made to be read as a standalone (IMO, the first three can be enjoyed individually), whatever the reason, I found myself putting off a series which I'd previously been certain I'd love. I've learned my lesson and am now breezing through these fantastic volumes (I'll be starting number four soon) and becoming more and more addicted to the characters, the world and the humour.
Will you enjoy this? Personally, I think it depends on whether the humour is your cup of tea. I also don't believe it would be fair to sell this series as merely a comedy; each volume is very different, some are darker and gorier than others, some are primarily mysteries, others not so much. But the humour is behind it all and is what, for me, turns this into something more than a regular urban fantasy, fairytale retelling. It's what makes these characters memorable and there's not much I like more than a funny villain - everyone has a sense of humour here. I, for one, am finding it more and more funny with every installment I read.
Another thing is the artwork, which I like a lot in this series. The art has to receive a mention when you're reading a graphic novel because it inevitably affects how you read the story and how you view the characters. I tend to prefer realistic drawings, as opposed to arty, scrawly messes that are supposed to set some kind of tone. Give me this instead any day:

This first volume opens with the discovery of Rose Red's destroyed apartment. The place has been turned on its head and blood is splattered on every surface. Bigby Wolf and Snow White must investigate... can all that blood really be Rose Red's? Is she dead? Who would have a reason to hurt her? This first story is enjoyable and, in my opinion, they just keep getting better.
.....................................................................
I just want to take this opportunity to also recommend the TV show Once Upon A Time. Originally, they were planning to make a show out of Fables but they modified it a bit and Once Upon A Time came out the other end. And it's a favourite of mine - you should check it out!
The Fables series has been one I've wanted to start since I first heard of it. Adult retellings of classic fairytales with a few touches of sex, violence and humour? SOLD! However, I talked myself out of it about a year ago when I foolishly picked up a random volume - nine, I believe - and didn't get it at all. Perhaps volume nine happens to be a bad apple in an otherwise excellent bunch, or perhaps that particular volume wasn't made to be read as a standalone (IMO, the first three can be enjoyed individually), whatever the reason, I found myself putting off a series which I'd previously been certain I'd love. I've learned my lesson and am now breezing through these fantastic volumes (I'll be starting number four soon) and becoming more and more addicted to the characters, the world and the humour.
Will you enjoy this? Personally, I think it depends on whether the humour is your cup of tea. I also don't believe it would be fair to sell this series as merely a comedy; each volume is very different, some are darker and gorier than others, some are primarily mysteries, others not so much. But the humour is behind it all and is what, for me, turns this into something more than a regular urban fantasy, fairytale retelling. It's what makes these characters memorable and there's not much I like more than a funny villain - everyone has a sense of humour here. I, for one, am finding it more and more funny with every installment I read.
Another thing is the artwork, which I like a lot in this series. The art has to receive a mention when you're reading a graphic novel because it inevitably affects how you read the story and how you view the characters. I tend to prefer realistic drawings, as opposed to arty, scrawly messes that are supposed to set some kind of tone. Give me this instead any day:

This first volume opens with the discovery of Rose Red's destroyed apartment. The place has been turned on its head and blood is splattered on every surface. Bigby Wolf and Snow White must investigate... can all that blood really be Rose Red's? Is she dead? Who would have a reason to hurt her? This first story is enjoyable and, in my opinion, they just keep getting better.
.....................................................................
I just want to take this opportunity to also recommend the TV show Once Upon A Time. Originally, they were planning to make a show out of Fables but they modified it a bit and Once Upon A Time came out the other end. And it's a favourite of mine - you should check it out!
Edited June 16, 2020
I absolutely adore this series. I've read through it at least 3 times at this point. Bill Willingham hit on an ingenious idea. What if the characters from fairy tales were real? And they are currently outcasts on our world. The first arc Legends in Exile introduces us to our main group of characters. It's a murder mystery. Someone has killed Rose Red and the town Fables have to get to the bottom of what happened.
I love the reinvention of all these old fables and fairy tales. They were often quite grim and Willingham doesn't shy away from that grimness as all. The book is filled with adult themes of sex, betrayal, and violence.
I love the reinvention of all these old fables and fairy tales. They were often quite grim and Willingham doesn't shy away from that grimness as all. The book is filled with adult themes of sex, betrayal, and violence.
Edited February 20, 2021
The Homelands where all the fantasy characters from human history(!) live was invaded by the deathly forces of The Adversary, and the war refugees like Snow White, Wolf, Beanstalk Jack, Old King Cole, Cinderella and many others now live in an enclave in New York - what a terrific concept! In this first volume the creative team introduce us to this reality by way of 'Bigby' Wolf and Snow White investigating the disappearance, and possible murder of her sister Rose Red! Delightful in so many ways, with well known characters evolved into modern, foul mouthed, world weary versions of themselves. So much potential for this book. A very neat and satisfying introduction - 8 out of 12.


February 8, 2009
Lovely lovely lovely.
Edited September 21, 2016
Legends in Exile by Bill Willingham and a team of illustrators begin the Fables series of adult graphic novels.
This is a very imaginative extension of fables such as Snow White, Old King Cole, the big bad wolf, Jack and the Beanstalk, etc. The idea is that the fables were exiled from their home lands by a common enemy, The Adversary, and relocated to New York but maintained a community of exiles called Fable Town.
Very entertaining and creative. One of the best scenes is a self-pitying monologue by Pinocchio.

This is a very imaginative extension of fables such as Snow White, Old King Cole, the big bad wolf, Jack and the Beanstalk, etc. The idea is that the fables were exiled from their home lands by a common enemy, The Adversary, and relocated to New York but maintained a community of exiles called Fable Town.
Very entertaining and creative. One of the best scenes is a self-pitying monologue by Pinocchio.

Edited January 20, 2016
3 Stars
So this Graphic Novel was very reminiscent of 'Once Upon a Time' for me. Our fairy tale creatures have been thrown into modern-day world and basically just have to deal with it... Awesome!! I love that shit.
Beyond being our introduction to the characters within the world, and some personalities that maybe don't exactly meet expectations, this first volume is a murder mystery.
Rose Red has disappeared, leaving behind an apartment splattered with blood and a big old mess.
Our unlikely Sherlock and Holmes Duo is B. Wolfe and Snow. This volume was so much fun, guys!! I thoroughly enjoyed getting to see how all these characters were getting on in the big, wide world of norms.
Everyone: Dude, what's with the three stars then??
Vampire Ninja: I didn't care for the art, at all. *shrugs*
So this Graphic Novel was very reminiscent of 'Once Upon a Time' for me. Our fairy tale creatures have been thrown into modern-day world and basically just have to deal with it... Awesome!! I love that shit.
Beyond being our introduction to the characters within the world, and some personalities that maybe don't exactly meet expectations, this first volume is a murder mystery.
Rose Red has disappeared, leaving behind an apartment splattered with blood and a big old mess.
Our unlikely Sherlock and Holmes Duo is B. Wolfe and Snow. This volume was so much fun, guys!! I thoroughly enjoyed getting to see how all these characters were getting on in the big, wide world of norms.
Everyone: Dude, what's with the three stars then??
Vampire Ninja: I didn't care for the art, at all. *shrugs*
Edited March 11, 2017
Because Gibsy said so.....
I paid good money for these Gibsy. You and your pasty skin better hope you didn't steer me wrong.
____________________________
Luckily, for Gibsy and all hisfriends acolytes, he will not be meeting an untimely demise via shrimp death.

Because I really liked this book.
The art is some of the most stunning art I have ever come across. And I'm not talking about Lan Medina's drawings which tell the story, though it was amazeballs too. I'm talking about James Jean's gorgeous works of art which separate the individual issues. Artwork which I want in poster form, on my bedroom wall.

This volume was a tiny bit lacking in the characterization department, but overall I was very entertained the whole way through and I zipped through this thing. I enjoyed reading about the specific characters and how their lives have shifted since their happily ever afters. Fairy tale legends live alongside regular New Yorkers (called Mundanes) ever since their kingdom was destroyed by an unknown and faceless enemy called The Adversary. It was kinda like a darker, better written this:

But without the angst. And the plotholes. And the crazy convoluted plots that didn't make sense. And DEFINITELY without these two.

Who (spoiler alert) completely ruined the show for me.
Anywhoo, these characters know about their magic, know about their homeland. Most of them lost their kingdoms and their riches and their titles and now have to figure out a way to live among us normal folk. Snow White is the mayor and the Big Bad Wolf is the sheriff. And that's all fine and dandy because after their worlds were destroyed, there was this great big grand amnesty thing and all the past crimes were forgiven, and in light of working together against the adversary, villains became heroes. And some heroes became villains.
Or maybe heroes and villains embody various shades of gray. That's better anyway.
Snow White's sister, Rose Red, appears to have been murdered, and the big bad wolf (otherwise known as Bigby) is on the case. Snow insists on tagging along. These two reminded me a bit of

Except Snow was a little bit more on the melodramatic side rather than the cute quirky side. She cried all the time. Like every other frame. It got on my nerves.
And like EVERY fairytale couple is divorced. Snow and Charming, Cinderella and her prince. The only ones who seem to be giving it a good run are beauty and the beast. And even they are far from the couple of the year.

I enjoyed the stellar storytelling chops from Willingham but also from the artist Lan Medina. A lot. I enjoyed the subtle hints into their true natures.

I also enjoyed much of the humor strewn throughout. It made me laugh.

I also enjoyed the needed bit of backstory we got into what really happened at The Homeland.

Poor little piggies. They never seem to catch a break.
The thing lacking for me was there wasn't really a character I liked all that much. Bigby has some potential, as does Bluebeard, but really, I found a lot of them shallow and whiny and pretentious. I'm hoping that future volumes can flesh out individual backstories because I want more.
So Gibsy shall live to see the sun rise and fall at least one more time. But I still have two more volumes to read before I make any decisions. I'm still watching you Gibsy.

I paid good money for these Gibsy. You and your pasty skin better hope you didn't steer me wrong.
____________________________
Luckily, for Gibsy and all his

Because I really liked this book.
The art is some of the most stunning art I have ever come across. And I'm not talking about Lan Medina's drawings which tell the story, though it was amazeballs too. I'm talking about James Jean's gorgeous works of art which separate the individual issues. Artwork which I want in poster form, on my bedroom wall.

This volume was a tiny bit lacking in the characterization department, but overall I was very entertained the whole way through and I zipped through this thing. I enjoyed reading about the specific characters and how their lives have shifted since their happily ever afters. Fairy tale legends live alongside regular New Yorkers (called Mundanes) ever since their kingdom was destroyed by an unknown and faceless enemy called The Adversary. It was kinda like a darker, better written this:

But without the angst. And the plotholes. And the crazy convoluted plots that didn't make sense. And DEFINITELY without these two.

Who (spoiler alert) completely ruined the show for me.
Anywhoo, these characters know about their magic, know about their homeland. Most of them lost their kingdoms and their riches and their titles and now have to figure out a way to live among us normal folk. Snow White is the mayor and the Big Bad Wolf is the sheriff. And that's all fine and dandy because after their worlds were destroyed, there was this great big grand amnesty thing and all the past crimes were forgiven, and in light of working together against the adversary, villains became heroes. And some heroes became villains.
Or maybe heroes and villains embody various shades of gray. That's better anyway.
Snow White's sister, Rose Red, appears to have been murdered, and the big bad wolf (otherwise known as Bigby) is on the case. Snow insists on tagging along. These two reminded me a bit of

Except Snow was a little bit more on the melodramatic side rather than the cute quirky side. She cried all the time. Like every other frame. It got on my nerves.
And like EVERY fairytale couple is divorced. Snow and Charming, Cinderella and her prince. The only ones who seem to be giving it a good run are beauty and the beast. And even they are far from the couple of the year.

I enjoyed the stellar storytelling chops from Willingham but also from the artist Lan Medina. A lot. I enjoyed the subtle hints into their true natures.

I also enjoyed much of the humor strewn throughout. It made me laugh.

I also enjoyed the needed bit of backstory we got into what really happened at The Homeland.

Poor little piggies. They never seem to catch a break.
The thing lacking for me was there wasn't really a character I liked all that much. Bigby has some potential, as does Bluebeard, but really, I found a lot of them shallow and whiny and pretentious. I'm hoping that future volumes can flesh out individual backstories because I want more.
So Gibsy shall live to see the sun rise and fall at least one more time. But I still have two more volumes to read before I make any decisions. I'm still watching you Gibsy.

February 19, 2018
Why am I just starting to read these? They are awesome
Displaying 1 - 10 of 3,592 reviews











